I chose PhotoStory3 because it was easy to use, and free. I could upload images, edit them, add narration, change the flow of the pictures, save as I went along, and import the final product with pretty much no hassle. I used a Logitech headset with a built in microphone (which I've used every week for online gaming and VOIP chats for years) and was very happy with the narration results. the only issue was the microphone settings didn't work within PhotoStory3 but I found I didn't change anything anyway, other than lowering my own playback volume on my headset. The only issue I had was applying background music. I use iTunes, and Apple and Microsoft seldom play together. I had no problem adding a file in Animoto, but I had to download a program to convert the MPa format that iTunes uses into an MP3 format for PhotoStory3. I used CNET as my download source because I've trusted that site for many, many years (great reviews, clean links, dad approved). For anyone else needing the same service, HERE is a link to the program I downloaded. It's lightweight, and fast. And free! As for my song choice, I went with Adele's "Rumour Has It" as a tongue-in-cheek nod to how rumors can make internet safety and cyber-bullying awareness so important. I used Photo Filtre (and have for a very long time) to create the images that I was missing - primarily the links and tips.
What I liked about the Animoto project was how quickly it all came together, and I thought it would be an awesome tool for a very brief assessment, something mid-unit to give an additional format option. What I liked about using PhotoStory3 was that it allowed for additional input - for each minute of finalized product, I spent about an hour fussing with settings, images, re-recording narration. I like the thought of giving it as a format option for a final assessment. It lends itself to group work as well, since the recording can be paused and picked back up, each slide or mid-slide.
Overall, I enjoyed using both Animoto, and PhotoStory3. I was sort of at a standstill when the digital Storytelling project started, partly because I'm not in a classroom and was lacking some immediate inspiration, and partly because it was so open-ended - both things I plan to factor into an assignment that requests this kind of output - the inspiration being part of the unit or lesson, and the focus narrowed to specific areas. I needed, however, the flexibility that a lack of focus provided, and I'm very happy with the outcome
The feedback from the VERY rough draft was more useful than I expected. I had intended to use background music, but the majority of comments suggested it, and I think I like what it adds, especially the specific song I chose. It was also encouraging to continue with the subject when everyone agreed on how important the topic was, so full speed, off I went
For the next digital story, I'm not sure if I would try yet another different format, since I really enjoyed what can be done with these two - but I think I'd aim for another Animoto that I could find many pictures for. My first was limited, and I'm more confident with creating some now.